Background Diabetes has been defined on the basis of different biomarkers, including fasting plasma glucose (FPG), 2-h plasma glucose in an oral glucose tolerance test (2hOGTT), and HbA(1c). We assessed the effect of different diagnostic definitions on both the population prevalence of diabetes and the classification of previously undiagnosed individuals as having diabetes versus not having diabetes in a pooled analysis of data from population-based health examination surveys in different regions.
Registro Sencillo
Registro Completo
Autor | Danaei, Goodarz Fahimi, Saman Lu, Yuan Zhou, Bin Hajifathalian, Kaveh Di Cesare, Mariachiara Lo, Wei-Cheng Reis-Santos, Barbara Cowan, Melanie J. Shaw, Jonathan E. Bentham, James Lin, John K. Bixby, Honor Magliano, Dianna Bovet, Pascal Miranda, J. Jaime Khang, Young-Ho Stevens, Gretchen A. Riley, Leanne M. Ali, Mohammed K. Ezzati, Majid Abdeen, Ziad A. Kadir, Khalid Abdul Abu-Rmeileh, Niveen M. Acosta-Cazares, Benjamin Aekplakorn, Wichai Aguilar-Salinas, Carlos A. Ahmadvand, Alireza Al Nsour, Mohannad Alkerwi, Ala'a Amouyel, Philippe Andersen, Lars Bo Anderssen, Sigmund A. Andrade, Dolores S. Anjana, Ranjit Mohan Aounallah-Skhiri, Hajer Aris, Tahir Arlappa, Nimmathota Arveiler, Dominique Assah, Felix K. Avdicova, Maria Balakrishna, Nagalla Bandosz, Piotr Barbagallo, Carlo M. Barcelo, Alberto Batieha, Anwar M. Baur, Louise A. Ben Romdhane, Habiba Bernabe-Ortiz, Antonio Bhargava, Santosh K. Bi, Yufang Bjerregaard, Peter Bjorkelund, Cecilia Blake, Margaret Blokstra, Anneke Bo, Simona Boehm, Bernhard O. Boissonnet, Carlos P. Bovet, Pascal Brajkovich, Imperia Breckenkamp, Juergen Brewster, Lizzy M. Brian, Garry R. Bruno, Graziella Bugge, Anna de Leon, Antonio Cabrera Can, Gunay Candido, Ana Paula C. Capuano, Vincenzo Carvalho, Maria J. Casanueva, Felipe F. Caserta, Carmelo A. Castetbon, Katia Chamukuttan, Snehalatha Chaturvedi, Nishi Chen, Chien-Jen Chen, Fangfang Chen, Shuohua Cheng, Ching-Yu Chetrit, Angela Chiou, Shu-Ti Cho, Yumi Chudek, Jerzy Cifkova, Renata Claessens, Frank Concin, Hans Cooper, Cyrus Cooper, Rachel Costanzo, Simona Cottel, Dominique Cowell, Chris Crujeiras, Ana B. D'Arrigo, Graziella Dallongeville, Jean Dankner, Rachel Dauchet, Luc de Gaetano, Giovanni De Henauw, Stefaan Deepa, Mohan Dehghan, Abbas Dhana, Klodian Di Castelnuovo, Augusto F. Djalalinia, Shirin Doua, Kouamelan Drygas, Wojciech Du, Yong Egbagbe, Eruke E. Eggertsen, Robert El Ati, Jalila Elosua, Roberto Erasmus, Rajiv T. Erem, Cihangir Ergor, Gul Eriksen, Louise la Penaa, Jorge Escobedo-De Fall, Caroline H. Farzadfar, Farshad Felix-Redondo, Francisco J. Ferguson, Trevor S. Fernandez-Berges, Daniel Ferrari, Marika Ferreccio, Catterina Finn, Joseph D. Foger, Bernhard Foo, Leng Huat Fouad, Heba M. Francis, Damian K. Franco, Maria do Carmo Franco, Oscar H. Frontera, Guillermo Furusawa, Takuro Gaciong, Zbigniew Galbarczyk, Andrzej Garnett, Sarah P. Gaspoz, Jean-Michel Gasull, Magda Gates, Louise Geleijnse, Johanna M. Ghasemain, Anoosheh Giampaoli, Simona Gianfagna, Francesco Giovannelli, Jonathan Gross, Marcela Gonzalez Rivas, Juan P. Gonzalez Gorbea, Mariano Bonet Gottrand, Frederic Grant, Janet F. Grodzicki, Tomasz Grontved, Anders Gruden, Grabriella Gu, Dongfeng Guan, Ong Peng Guerrero, Ramiro Guessous, Idris Guimaraes, Andre L. Gutierrez, Laura Hardy, Rebecca Kumar, Rachakulla Hari He, Jiang Heidemann, Christin Hihtaniemi, Ilpo Tapani Ho, Sai Yin Ho, Suzanne C. Hofman, Albert Russo, Andrea R. V. Hormiga, Claudia M. Horta, Bernardo L. Houti, Leila Hussieni, Abdullatif S. Huybrechts, Inge Hwalla, Nahla Iacoviello, Licia Iannone, Anna G. Ibrahim, Mohsen M. Ikeda, Nayu Ikram, M. Arfan Irazola, Vilma E. Islam, Muhammad Iwasaki, Masanori Jacobs, Jeremy M. Jafar, Tazeen Jasienska, Grazyna Jiang, Chao Qiang Jonas, Jost B. Joshi, Pradeep Kafatos, Anthony Kalter-Leibovici, Ofra Kasaeian, Amir Katz, Joanne Kaur, Prabhdeep Kavousi, Maryam Kelishadi, Roya Kengne, Andre P. Kersting, Mathilde Khader, Yousef Saleh Khang, Young-Ho Kiechl, Stefan Kim, Jeongseon Kiyohara, Yutaka Kolsteren, Patrick Korrovits, Paul Koskinen, Seppo Kratzer, Wolfgang Kromhout, Daan Kula, Krzysztof Kurjata, Pawel Kyobutungi, Catherine Lachat, Carl Laid, Youcef Lam, Tai Hing Landrove, Orlando Lanska, Vera Lappas, Georg Laxmaiah, Avula Leclercq, Catherine Lee, Jeannette Lee, Jeonghee Lehtimaki, Terho Lekhraj, Rampal Leon-Munoz, Luz M. Li, Yanping Lim, Wei-Yen Lima-Costa, M. Fernanda Lin, Hsien-Ho Lin, Xu Lissner, Lauren Lorbeer, Roberto Lozano, Jose Eugenio Lundqvist, Annamari Lytsy, Per Ma, Guansheng Machado-Coelho, George L. L. Machi, Suka Maggi, Stefania Magliano, Dianna Makdisse, Marcia Rao, Kodavanti Mallikharjuna Manios, Yannis Manzato, Enzo Margozzini, Paula Marques-Vidal, Pedro Martorell, Reynaldo Masoodi, Shariq R. Matsha, Tandi E. Mbanya, Jean Claude N. McFarlane, Shelly R. McGarvey, Stephen T. McLachlan, Stela McNulty, Breige A. Mediene-Benchekor, Sounnia Meirhaeghe, Aline Menezes, Ana Maria B. Merat, Shahin Meshram, Indrapal I. Mi, Jie Miquel, Juan Francisco Miranda, J. Jaime Mohamed, Mostafa K. Mohammad, Kazem Mohan, Viswanathan Yusoff, Muhammad Fadhli Mohd Moller, Niels C. Molnar, Denes Mondo, Charles K. Moreno, Luis A. Morgan, Karen Moschonis, George Mossakowska, Malgorzata Mostafa, Aya Mota, Jorge Muiesan, Maria L. Muller-Nurasyid, Martina Mursu, Jaakko Nagel, Gabriele Namesna, Jana Nang, Ei Ei K. Nangia, Vinay B. Navarrete-Munoz, Eva Maria Ndiaye, Ndeye Coumba Nervi, Flavio Nguyen, Nguyen D. Nieto-Martinez, Ramfi S. E. Ning, Guang Ninomiya, Toshiharu Noale, Marianna Noto, Davide Ochoa-Aviles, Angelica M. Oh, Kyungwon Onat, Altan Osmond, Clive Otero, Johanna A. Palmieri, Luigi Panda-Jonas, Songhomitra Panza, Francesco Parsaeian, Mahboubeh Peixoto, Sergio Viana Pereira, Alexandre C. Peters, Annette Peykari, Niloofar Pilav, Aida Pitakaka, Freda Piwonska, Aleksandra Piwonski, Jerzy Plans-Rubio, Pedro Porta, Miquel Portegies, Marileen L. P. Poustchi, Hossein Pradeepa, Rajendra Price, Jacqueline F. Punab, Margus Qasrawi, Radwan F. Qorbani, Mostafa Raitakari, Olli Rao, Sudha Ramachandra Ramachandran, Ambady Ramos, Rafel Rampal, Sanjay Rathmann, Wolfgang Redon, Josep Reganit, Paul Ferdinand M. Rigo, Fernando Robinson, Sian M. Robitaille, Cynthia Rodriguez, Laura A. Rodriguez-Artalejo, Fernando Rodriguez-Perez, Maria del Cristo Rojas-Martinez, Rosalba Romaguera, Dora Rosengren, Annika Rubinstein, Adolfo Rui, Ornelas Ruiz-Betancourt, Blanca Sandra Rutkowski, Marcin Sabanayagam, Charumathi Sachdev, Harshpal S. Saidi, Olfa Sakarya, Sibel Salanave, Benoit Salonen, Jukka T. Salvetti, Massimo Sanchez-Abanto, Jose Nunes, Renata Santos, Rute Sardinha, Luis B. Scazufca, Marcia Schargrodsky, Herman Scheidt-Nave, Christa Shaw, Jonathan E. Shibuya, Kenji Shin, Youchan Shiri, Rahman Siantar, Rosalynn Sibai, Abla M. Simon, Mary Simons, Judith Simons, Leon A. Sjostrom, Michael Slowikowska-Hilczer, Jolanta Slusarczyk, Przemyslaw Smeeth, Liam Snijder, Marieke B. Solfrizzi, Vincenzo Sonestedt, Emily Soumare, Aicha Staessen, Jan A. Steene-Johannessen, Jostein Stehle, Peter Stein, Aryeh D. Stessman, Jochanan Stockl, Doris Stokwiszewski, Jakub Strufaldi, Maria Wany Sun, Chien-An Sundstrom, Johan Suriyawongpaisal, Paibul Sy, Rody G. Tai, E. Shyong Tarawneh, Mohammed Tarqui-Mamani, Carolina B. Thijs, Lutgarde Tolstrup, Janne S. Topbas, Murat Torrent, Maties Traissac, Pierre Trinh, Oanh T. H. Tulloch-Reid, Marshall K. Tuomainen, Tomi-Pekka Turley, Maria L. Tzourio, Christophe Ueda, Peter Ukoli, Flora M. Ulmer, Hanno Valdivia, Gonzalo Van Valkengoed, Irene G. M. Vanderschueren, Dirk Vanuzzo, Diego Vega, Tomas Velasquez-Melendez, Gustavo Veronesi, Giovanni Verschuren, Monique Vioque, Jesus Virtanen, Jyrki Visvikis-Siest, Sophie Viswanathan, Bharathi Vollenweider, Peter Voutilainen, Sari Wade, Alisha N. Wagner, Aline Walton, Janette Mohamud, Wan Nazaimoon Wan Wang, Ming-Dong Wang, Ya Xing Wannamethee, S. Goya Weerasekera, Deepa Whincup, Peter H. Widhalm, Kurt Wiecek, Andrzej Wilks, Rainford J. Willeit, Johann Wojtyniak, Bogdan Wong, Tien Yin Woo, Jean Woodward, Mark Wu, Aleksander Giwercman Wu, Frederick C. Wu, Shou Ling Xu, Haiquan Yang, Xiaoguang Ye, Xingwang Yoshihara, Akihiro Younger-Coleman, Novie O. Zambon, Sabina Zargar, Abdul Hamid Zdrojewski, Tomasz Zhao, Wenhua Zheng, Yingfeng |
Título | Effects of diabetes definition on global surveillance of diabetes prevalence and diagnosis: a pooled analysis of 96 population-based studies with 331288 participants |
Revista | Lancet diabetes & endocrinology |
ISSN | 2213-8587 |
ISSN electrónico | 2213-8595 |
Volumen | 3 |
Número de publicación | 8 |
Página inicio | 624 |
Página final | 637 |
Fecha de publicación | 2015 |
Resumen | Background Diabetes has been defined on the basis of different biomarkers, including fasting plasma glucose (FPG), 2-h plasma glucose in an oral glucose tolerance test (2hOGTT), and HbA(1c). We assessed the effect of different diagnostic definitions on both the population prevalence of diabetes and the classification of previously undiagnosed individuals as having diabetes versus not having diabetes in a pooled analysis of data from population-based health examination surveys in different regions. Methods We used data from 96 population-based health examination surveys that had measured at least two of the biomarkers used for defining diabetes. Diabetes was defined using HbA(1c) (HbA(1c) >= 6 . 5% or history of diabetes diagnosis or using insulin or oral hypoglycaemic drugs) compared with either FPG only or FPG-or-2hOGTT definitions (FPG >= 7 . 0 mmol/L or 2hOGTT >= 11 . 1 mmol/L or history of diabetes or using insulin or oral hypoglycaemic drugs). We calculated diabetes prevalence, taking into account complex survey design and survey sample weights. We compared the prevalences of diabetes using different definitions graphically and by regression analyses. We calculated sensitivity and specificity of diabetes diagnosis based on HbA1c compared with diagnosis based on glucose among previously undiagnosed individuals (ie, excluding those with history of diabetes or using insulin or oral hypoglycaemic drugs). We calculated sensitivity and specificity in each survey, and then pooled results using a random-effects model. We assessed the sources of heterogeneity of sensitivity by meta-regressions for study characteristics selected a priori. Findings Population prevalence of diabetes based on FPG- or-2hOGTT was correlated with prevalence based on FPG alone (r= 0 . 98), but was higher by 2-6 percentage points at different prevalence levels. Prevalence based on HbA(1c) was lower than prevalence based on FPG in 42 . 8% of age-sex-survey groups and higher in another 41 . 6%; in the other 15 . 6%, the two definitions provided similar prevalence estimates. The variation across studies in the relation between glucose-based and HbA(1c)-based prevalences was partly related to participants' age, followed by natural logarithm of per person gross domestic product, the year of survey, mean BMI, and whether the survey population was national, subnational, or from specific communities. Diabetes defined as HbA(1c) 6 . 5% or more had a pooled sensitivity of 52 . 8% (95% CI 51 . 3-54 . 3%) and a pooled specificity of 99 . 74% (99 . 71-99 . 78%) compared with FPG 7 . 0 mmol/L or more for diagnosing previously undiagnosed participants; sensitivity compared with diabetes defined based on FPG-or-2hOGTT was 30 . 5% (28 . 7-32 . 3%). None of the preselected study-level characteristics explained the heterogeneity in the sensitivity of HbA(1c) versus FPG. Interpretation Different biomarkers and definitions for diabetes can provide different estimates of population prevalence of diabetes, and differentially identify people without previous diagnosis as having diabetes. Using an HbA(1c)-based definition alone in health surveys will not identify a substantial proportion of previously undiagnosed people who would be considered as having diabetes using a glucose-based test. |
Derechos | acceso restringido |
DOI | 10.1016/S2213-8587(15)00129-1 |
Enlace | |
Id de publicación en WoS | WOS:000358540100018 |
Tema ODS | 03 Good Health and Well-being |
Tema ODS español | 03 Salud y bienestar |
Tipo de documento | artículo |